>Mark G
> in respect of the OP stated desire to find a solution to his issue
>roo
> I don't mean to divert this thread, but I hope you can give different approaches a fair shake (pun intended)
Well thank you, but feel free to debate, as I, anyway, as learner, do enjoy the discussion.
As someone approaching this world, it is quite interesting to see that each knot seems to have
his supporters, just like some sport team :-)
I have looked online for the clove hitch too, but it seems that the site "animatedknot" was
warning about it, stating some "dangers" (see:
http://www.animatedknots.com/cloveend/)
Clearly, I understand that there could be no absolute winners, uniformly dominating under all
circummstances, but depending on the specific situation, surrounding conditions,
and the direction of applied forces any knot can possibly offer some value.
By the way, what are other candidates that are suggested for the 5 knots I currently have?
As to the gnat hitch I don't have much diversified experience to suggest anything on general performances.
One thing that I noted is that, although the knot seemed quite "simple", when I tried to replicate (as an exercise)
day after day, it without a visual guide, I had initially some difficulty and had to go look up again.
Looks like this stuff needs anyway some daily practice to be remembered and permanently stored in the brain.
I think the top "overhand" knot is way too "ugly" (although possibly effective to simply create
the attachment loop) and should be changed with something else.
In my various explorations on the web, I have seen the so called "alpine butterfly", which at first look
seemed good looking. However, after playing with it for a few minutes, I realized that the 2 ends
of the rope come out of the knot one on top of the other (and not at the same precise height), and that
does not seem desirable in my case.