(I was actually able to find it using search.)
As I have complained many times, "Search" is not working properly in this Forum, so I have to use "Google" many times ! : It shows the posts with a
peculiar order, and it shows any posts which include the word we search
IT wants !
It does nt show the very first post, and, many times, it doesn't even show the thread in the title of which this word is included... So, you were just
lucky with the Andalusian hitch - if you search now, you will find the Andalusian hitch original thread only after
5 other posts - moreover, from this thread, you will find only the second of the end post ...
...especially with the overhand lock.
Which overhand lock ? What do you mean ?
The trade off for better tail gripping strength is that it can be harder to pull the tails to tighten the binding action, somewhat.
Indeed, this is the main problem with all those knots...I find very difficult to decide how much I want to secure the Ends, so they will not become too entangled, and so difficult to pull and re-adjusted. AND, this would be decided for a great variety of materials ! Difficult !
Various rope material and construction show me that some of these types of binders are better with one than the other.
I consider this a disadvantage of those knots... If they are too material-depended, they are not relying in their geometry, but in the particular characteristics of the rope - so their success is circumstantial. We want knots that work adequately well when tied on all ordinary materials, even if they would behave better when they tied on some than when tied on some others - but a knot that works only on very soft or only on very stiff ropes, is a failure, IMHO.